Retention Desk · Guides · Find lapsed members

How to find lapsed members in your gym software

Before you can win anyone back, you need the list. Your member software can give it to you, but often not from one screen: canceled members, frozen members and members who simply stopped coming can sit in different places. Here is where they hide in five common systems, how to merge them into one list and who to send to first.

By Thomas Sousa, founder of Retention Desk and an NCEP certified personal trainer in St. Petersburg, Florida. Updated November 18, 2026.

Three groups make a lapsed list

A lapsed list is wider than your canceled tab. It has three groups:

  • Canceled or expired. Members whose plan ended in the last six months.
  • On hold or frozen. Members who paused and never came back to class.
  • Quiet but active. Members who still show as Active but have not been in for 30 days or more.

If you run trials or intro offers, add a fourth group: leads who tried a class and never joined. They already know where to park and what a class feels like.

The hour it takes is worth it. In the Health and Fitness Association's 2025 benchmark of 175 operators in 27 countries, the average operator kept 66.4 percent of members in 2024, so about one in three left that year. The people who left are still records in your software.

PushPress

Go to People in the left menu. Click Filter, choose Plan and pick the plan, then add Status and select canceled or paused.

For cancellations, set the Churn Date Range to the last six months and use Export to CSV if you want a copy.

Filters do not stay in the page address, so set them again each time.

Two things to know. A canceled or completed plan makes someone an Ex Member, but a paused plan still counts as a Member, so paused people will not show up on an Ex Member list. And leads are people on a trial, guest pass or intro offer who have not bought a membership.

Wodify

Wodify is the clearest case of members hiding. Cancelling a membership leaves the client Active unless someone also changes the Deactivate Account toggle, so many canceled members never reach the Inactive tab.

  • Deactivated accounts: go to People, then Clients, and open the Inactive tab. Tick the top checkbox, click the three dot icon and choose Export. The export has no cancel date, so keep people whose Last Attendance Date is within six months.
  • Canceled but still Active: go to Analytics, then Standard Reports, open the Attendance tab and run Most Recent Attendance.
  • On hold: go to Analytics, then Reports, open the Membership tab and run On Hold Memberships.
  • Leads: go to People, then Leads, and use the Board view. New, Trial, Contacted and Disqualified leads never joined.

Gymdesk

Open Members in the main menu and go to the Canceled tab. Gymdesk counts both canceled and expired memberships as canceled.

Click Filter to narrow the list. If you track attendance, each person's last training session shows in the list, which also finds current members who stopped coming.

To mark the group, click Select, tick the people you want, then Actions and Tag Members. Use a fresh tag for each campaign.

Trial people sit under the Visitors tab, not Leads.

Momence and Arketa

Studio software tends to find lapsed clients by attendance rather than by status.

Momence: go to Customers, then Customer List, then the Customer Segmentation button. Filter visits to exactly 0 in the last 30 days and save the segment with a clear name. No Momence filter lists canceled or frozen customers on their own, but the zero visit filter catches them.

Arketa: go to Clients, then Segments, and create a new segment. Add an Attended reservation condition of at least 1 time 30 to 180 days ago, and a second of exactly 0 times in the last 30 days, combined with All. For former members, add a Pricing option condition for expired subscriptions. The built in Leads segment holds people with no purchases and no reservations.

Merge the lists and pick who goes first

Put the pulls together and remove anyone who appears twice. Then sort by how recently they left.

  • Send to people who left in the last two months first, then months three to six. Recent leavers still remember your coaches and your schedule.
  • Leave out anyone who asked not to hear from you, anyone who left on bad terms and anyone who is already back.
  • Text only people who agreed to get texts, and keep an unsubscribe link on every email.
  • Before each later message, take out anyone who has come back since the first one.

What one lapsed member is worth

Count the list in dues. Here is a worked example. At $69 a month, the average US membership fee in 2024 in the Health and Fitness Association's 2025 US Consumer Report, one member who comes back and stays a year adds $828 in dues. Your own price and numbers will differ.

Start with one pull this week

Pick the one pull that fits your software and run it this week, even if you send nothing yet. Step by step pages for 30 systems, each with the vendor help articles it was checked against, are in our free software guides. When the list is ready, the five messages to send over ten days are on our free win back email templates page.

Want us to look first? Our free Retention Snapshot is a one page look at your gym from your website, reviews and social media, with what is working, where members may be slipping, three fixes you can use this month and a sample win back email in your voice.

Sources

Want this written for your gym or studio?

Get a free Retention Snapshot and a Free 10 Day COMEBACK Campaign, built around your classes, coaches and offer and ready to send from the tools you already use. No cost and no contract.